PFM reserves the right to remove any post.
Please do not use for commercial use or to redirect people
to your commercial site or we will have to remove your post.

Main  Art Talk  Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
	Topic: Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
?	posted 3/17/2003 10:08:00 PM by Rare Toby E. Rosenthal Painting E-mail: section1oppsfde@yahoo.com	[ Post your reply ]
	I have a original painting of "The Cardinals Portrait" by Toby E. Rosenthal 1896! I am looking for an appraisal and maybe willing to sell, any info will be helpful, thanks!
!	posted 2/20/2013 9:12:00 AM by eric E-mail: egard2383@yahoo.com
	I am looking for an estamated value of the Toby Rosenthal "cardinal sleeping" print in antique frame
!	posted 7/24/2012 4:07:00 PM by silvia.decastro.tabor@gmail.com E-mail: silvia.decastro.tabor@gmail.com
	I,m looking for appraisal and maybe willing to sell
!	posted 4/16/2012 2:30:00 AM by cece E-mail: antiquesandI@yahoo.com
	looking to see the value on the cardinal portrait please let me know.
!	posted 12/1/2011 5:26:00 PM by eduardo E-mail: edulalo78@gmail.com
	Hello I have Toby''s picture. E.Rosenthal Munich.1896, Since I can see if it is original or not. If it is original, that value can have. And if it is a copy it has value. To have if they can say to me or to help. The picture is a cardinal sat like slept and a painter of foot. Thank you very much. My e-mail is edulalo78@gmail.com
!	posted 11/24/2011 1:46:00 PM by David Bloomfield E-mail: marydecoite@comcast.net
	How much is a 1896 Toby E. Rosenthall "sleeping bishop" painting worth?
Main  Art Talk  Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
	Topic: Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
?	posted 3/17/2003 10:08:00 PM by Rare Toby E. Rosenthal Painting E-mail: section1oppsfde@yahoo.com	[ Post your reply ]
	I have a original painting of "The Cardinals Portrait" by Toby E. Rosenthal 1896! I am looking for an appraisal and maybe willing to sell, any info will be helpful, thanks!
!	posted 5/3/2010 8:27:00 PM by jesse E-mail: chuchoguillen@yahoo.com
	I have in my posession two beautiful oil paintings by Toby E Rosenthal, it is quite interesting to know that Mr. Rosenthal lived in New Haven, Ct , I also live in New Haven, Ct if there is any interest in buying this two beautiful paintings feel free to contact me at 203-675-1138 and my email is chuchoguillen@yahoo.com if you prefer to communicate that way.
!	posted 12/24/2007 12:07:00 PM by George E-mail: george@emkay.org.uk
	hi there i also have toby rosenthal painting which was giving to me by me aunt just wondering if it could be original or worth money its His Madonna, 1908 the senie it doesn''t look like a poster copy its also painted on a gold paper just wondering does someone have original of this painting as i think this one came from a church as my aunt use to work in the church here is the size of it 44cm x 63cm its also in a nice frame
!	posted 3/24/2007 9:31:00 AM by judie flynn E-mail: akaalbany@juno.com
	I have an oil of the cardinal by Toby Rosenthal has been in the family as long as I can remember was given to me by an uncle in his eighties when I was a young girl in 1967. Said the cardinal was some kind of relative? Malloy or something like that?? He stressed it was a real painting, the artist was a family friend, And I should keep it always. Now I have seen it on line and I am wondering what it is.
!	posted 1/26/2007 10:32:00 AM by Gene Theobald E-mail: gene.theobald@morganstanley.com
	If any one has The Cardinal Portrait by Toby E. Rosenthal for sale, please call me. (713) 965-8746. I am very interested in purchasing this for my wife.
!	posted 9/8/2006 8:09:00 PM by Star E-mail: abrightstar2001@aol.com
	I have a numbered print of a painting from Toby E. Rosenthal titled Seine Madonna, 1908. The number on the back of the frame is 08406. It looks like an original because it has what looks like paint stokes on it. But I researched and know that the original is on display at the Museum of San Fransisco. I would be interested to know if it is of any value. Thank you
Main  Art Talk  Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
	Topic: Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
?	posted 3/17/2003 10:08:00 PM by Rare Toby E. Rosenthal Painting E-mail: section1oppsfde@yahoo.com	[ Post your reply ]
	I have a original painting of "The Cardinals Portrait" by Toby E. Rosenthal 1896! I am looking for an appraisal and maybe willing to sell, any info will be helpful, thanks!
!	posted 8/25/2006 7:01:00 PM by Marsh from indy E-mail: marshalynn22@yahoo.com
	i have a 1966 original painting by an african american artist by the name of H.Turner. He has since painted several presidents including Gerald Ford. This painting is in a gallery in Minnesota. Please tell me what this artist's unknown painting may be worth. Thank you for your time and im hoping you will email me back with some information.
!	posted 8/12/2006 4:59:00 PM by Alisa E-mail: whuttever1a@yahoo.com
	I have a "the Cardinal's Portrait" painting purchased in 1946, #20491. Does anyone know the value? or anything else?
!	posted 7/29/2006 4:10:00 PM by miguel ayala E-mail: ayala_cindy@yahoo.com
	i have a painting of toby e rosental munich 1896. a monk painting a cardinal. i am intrested in selling. i dont know much about it but it is signed by rosental. if you are interested or have any information that may be helpful please contact me by email or at (775)635-0698
!	posted 1/20/2006 10:52:00 AM by HELEN mASON E-mail: SHADYPINESHELEN@MCHSI.COM
	We have print 4770 cardinals portrait purchased in 1952. Does anyone know the value. Would appreciate reply.
!	posted 7/1/2005 4:05:00 PM by ursula E-mail: jakster@optonline.net
	Just wondering did anyone get back ot you about a price on you'r rosenthal? Because I have one as well. Also does yours feel like it on cardboared?
Main  Art Talk  Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
	Topic: Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
?	posted 3/17/2003 10:08:00 PM by Rare Toby E. Rosenthal Painting E-mail: section1oppsfde@yahoo.com	[ Post your reply ]
	I have a original painting of "The Cardinals Portrait" by Toby E. Rosenthal 1896! I am looking for an appraisal and maybe willing to sell, any info will be helpful, thanks!
!	posted 1/30/2005 6:00:00 PM by j.grancio E-mail: grancio@sbcglobal.net
	I HAVE A (CARDINALS PORTRAIT) 1896.DONT KNOW MUCH ABOUT IT.IF ANY ONE INTERESTED IN PURCHASING.DROP ME A E-MAIL. GRANCIO@SBCGLOBAL.NET.
!	posted 1/24/2005 11:31:00 PM by unknown E-mail: tomahawk@msn.com
	i have a painting of tobe E Rosenthal the Cardinal's Portait in oil with an ID number 27108 and i want some info you can give me
!	posted 4/27/2004 5:31:00 PM by Sandra E-mail: syj_1234@yahoo.com
	Can you tell me which museum in San Francisco the Cardnial Portrait is hanging? I have been looking on line and not finding very much. The name of the museum would be very helpful.
!	posted 4/9/2004 5:43:00 PM by Eli Rodes E-mail: LittleHili@aol.com
	Afraid to tell you, but your painting is definitely not an original. There are many prints in circulation and the original has been in a museum in San Francisco for many, many years. It is a very large canvas and probably wouldn't fit on any wall in your house.
!	posted 4/6/2004 10:18:00 PM by Sandra Fry E-mail: laser204@msn.com
	Hello, I also have just realized that the picture on the wall is indeed something of value. I believe I have a print of the Cardinal Sitting. I would be happy to hear about how much this is worth. I thank you in advance, Sandy
Main  Art Talk  Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
	Topic: Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
?	posted 3/17/2003 10:08:00 PM by Rare Toby E. Rosenthal Painting E-mail: section1oppsfde@yahoo.com	[ Post your reply ]
	I have a original painting of "The Cardinals Portrait" by Toby E. Rosenthal 1896! I am looking for an appraisal and maybe willing to sell, any info will be helpful, thanks!
!	posted 2/24/2004 2:04:00 PM by joanne Leinow E-mail: joanneleinow@hotmail.com
	I just got at a garage sale The Cardinal's Portrait by Toby E. Rosenthal. I am assuming it is a print. I am also searching for more information. Thanks
!	posted 1/21/2004 11:55:00 AM by Brenda Cote E-mail: brcote@san.rr.com
	I have an Antique framed print of Cardinal Sleeping by Toby E. Rosental that was handed down in our family, can you tell me more about artist and what this print is worth? Thank you
!	posted 12/30/2003 10:05:00 PM by Don E-mail: wizbanG@AOL.COM
	I also grew up with an oil of this portrait hanging on the wall in my grandmothers livingroom. I don't know which family member received it when she passed, but I think that there are many copies of the particular print ou there. Regardless of wether they are original's or copy's by the artist, his work is wonderful in their detail and in the feelings that they convey. For those that are looking for copies or prints, it isn't hard to find them on line. Best of luck to you.
!	posted 12/30/2003 10:04:00 PM by Don E-mail: joeciv@att.net
	I also grew up with an oil of this portrait hanging on the wall in my grandmothers livingroom. I don't know which family member received it when she passed, but I think that there are many copies of the particular print ou there. Regardless of wether they are original's or copy's by the artist, his work is wonderful in their detail and in the feelings that they convey. For those that are looking for copies or prints, it isn't hard to find them on line. Best of luck to you.
!	posted 12/15/2003 5:09:00 AM by Brendan Bouey E-mail: bbouey@aol.com
	PS: I am on here,and found this site, trying to find a print of this painting also. If anyone can help it would be much appreciated.
Main  Art Talk  Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
	Topic: Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
?	posted 3/17/2003 10:08:00 PM by Rare Toby E. Rosenthal Painting E-mail: section1oppsfde@yahoo.com	[ Post your reply ]
	I have a original painting of "The Cardinals Portrait" by Toby E. Rosenthal 1896! I am looking for an appraisal and maybe willing to sell, any info will be helpful, thanks!
!	posted 12/15/2003 5:02:00 AM by Brendan Bouey E-mail: bbouey@aol.com
	I'm sure I remember the original of the" sleeping cardinal" hanging in the Palace of Legion of Honor in SF back in the 70's or '80's. I remember because growing up we had a print of this hanging over the mantle in our frontroom in SF. Could there be another similiar original painted? Good luck to you I can't wait to hear the rest of your story.
!	posted 10/19/2003 12:02:00 AM by F. M. Bastone E-mail: synergybydesign@comcast.net
	We bought the "Seine Madonna, 1908" at an estate sale for .50 cents. His signature appears on the painting as Toby E. Rosenthal, Munich 1908... there is nothing else. We went to this estate sale several days in a row, this painting kept grabbing my attention, but it was marked far too high... the last day of the estate sale everything you could fit in a bag went for $5.00, I grabbed the painting. I am estimating that we spent maybe $0.50 on it, but it could be lower. How do I know if it is a print? or an original? PLEASE HELP!! Thank you, in advance.
!	posted 9/10/2003 8:18:00 PM by rudy E-mail: finchrg@webtv.net
	Still looking to find a print or copy of the Cardinal's Portrait by Rosenthal, not an original painting. Any ideas or recommendations?
!	posted 9/4/2003 11:56:00 PM by Gerri Purcell E-mail: gerrkay @hotmail.com
	I was caught up in the conversation about the portrait-Portrait of a Cardinal. I purchased this picture at a auction and have been trying to get any information I can about it. All I know is it is by Toby E. Rosenthal-Munich-1896. I do not know how to research on this and any info whould be appreciated. Thanks!!! Gerri Purcell
!	posted 6/17/2003 7:49:00 PM by George Hames E-mail: Geopam35@att.net
	Is your painting of the Cardinal in oil or water color? We have an old painting by Toby E. Rosenthal given to my mother by an old wealthy male friend. We have wanted to find out if we have an original or a print. What did you find out about your painting? Is it the original? We can see his signature on this printing which appears to be mounted on wood, very well, but the date is not so clear because of the frame covering it and the name of the printing. We have always enjoyed the humor in this painting and got it when my mother passed away. Thanks for your reply, George Hames
Main  Art Talk  Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
	Topic: Toby E. Rosenthal Painting 1896
?	posted 3/17/2003 10:08:00 PM by Rare Toby E. Rosenthal Painting E-mail: section1oppsfde@yahoo.com	[ Post your reply ]
	I have a original painting of "The Cardinals Portrait" by Toby E. Rosenthal 1896! I am looking for an appraisal and maybe willing to sell, any info will be helpful, thanks!
!	posted 4/26/2003 4:50:00 AM by Maxwell Roberts E-mail: maxwellroberts@btconnect.com
	Toby Edward Rosenthal paintings do go through the auction markets infrequently. Prices obviously depend on subject, size and the prospect of two people bidding against each other! Prices as far as I can make out vary greatly a 44" x 72" painting went through auction a few years ago for $30,000, but a monk painting size 13" x 16" went through auctioneers Weidlers for $1108. If you do want to sell,your best bet might be to go to someone like Christies but put a reserve that you would be happy with which is not going to be too offputting to the bidder, but will be tempting. Best of luck!
!	posted 4/25/2003 4:25:00 PM by DBarker E-mail: rdbarker5@attbi.com
	I have what I think is a print of a Rosenthal painting. It is a picture of a boy carving a statue of Mary. On the bottom it says Toby E. Rosental PIWX, Munich 1908 Segen der Arbeit. I don't know where to start research on this. Thank you.
!	posted 4/9/2003 2:03:00 PM by Tammy Knight E-mail: shzthbomb@aol.com
	Wow!!!...If you own an origial Toby Edward Rosenthal, it's most certainly valuable. Check on line under search for legion of honor. Look for "Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco" They should have an address and phone number. This particular museum has several of his original painting on loan. One is the "Seine Madonna, 1908" Which is my favorite. It's on loan to them by the Stern Jacobs Family. They will definately know who would want to purchase it and it's value. Toby Rosenthal was a painter born in New Haven, Conn. (1848-1917) and studied under Henri Bacon and under Fortunato Arrio Francisco, then in Munich under Carl von Piloty in 1865-Munich 1917. Let me know if this info is helpful or not, I can check some other sources, but your going to be astonished at the value...good luck!
!	posted 3/24/2003 10:55:00 AM by Judy Groover E-mail: judy.groover@southtrust.com
	I would be most interested in knowing what you find out. I have the print, and it has always been one of my favorites.